Overcrowding reaches crisis level in Mayo University Hospital

This renewed focus comes just over a year since an inquest into the death of Patrick Rowland heard he spent upwards of 42 hours on a trolley there.

A verdict of accidental death was returned after he was found drowned in Castlebar river having left the hospital in his pyjamas on a night in January 2023.

Dr Lisa Cunningham, consultant in emergency medicine at Mayo University Hospital, said overcrowding is at “unheard of” levels now.

โ€œWe absolutely have patients who are multiple hours in the back of an ambulance, getting treatment โ€” getting their IV antibiotic, having had bloods already drawn,โ€ she said.

โ€œWeโ€™re having now to assign doctors to the ambulances because itโ€™s a space to treat a patient. There is physically no space in the emergency department.โ€

Various barriers are behind the overcrowding, she suggested.

โ€œEverybody has to come to the emergency department in Mayo to access hospital care,โ€ she said.

Almost a third of ED patients could be treated at injury units

She estimated up to 30% of their ED patients could be treated by injury units.

However unlike Limerick for example, Mayo does not have this.

It does not operate a Pathfinder ambulance service. In Cork, for example, older patients who call 999 can be treated at home by paramedics if appropriate.

โ€œSo this is a gap even before they reach into the emergency department,โ€ she said.

Irish College of GP data shows 79 GPs per 100,000 of population in Mayo when 100 is recommended.

Dr Cunningham said this and other shortages mean: โ€œWe donโ€™t have a lot of the care in the community to help keep people out (of hospital).โ€

She called for solutions to the whole jigsaw not just the โ€œone little partโ€ in the ED.

Dr Cunningham said the “complexities” they are facing can be “just for us” as she said solutions might not transfer between regions.

โ€œSo when you have somebody that comes along with a bit of a sledgehammer and says โ€˜this is whatโ€™s happening in Mayoโ€™ you instead need to take us and every other ED based on the population demographics we actually treat,โ€ she said.

‘Dangerous staffing shortfalls’ in Mayo

The Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation (INMO) is balloting emergency care nurses in response to โ€œdangerous staffing shortfallsโ€ in Mayo.

Assistant director of industrial relations for the area, Colm Porter said long talks did not bring adequate answers.

He said nurses now feel risks being posed to patients due to ongoing understaffing problems “have become too significant and that their concerns are not being taken seriously”.

Nurse have regularly reported a chronic staffing shortfall for two years, he added, without getting โ€œan adequate responseโ€.

The union called for the safe staffing framework to be applied, saying nurse numbers do not match patient numbers.

Mr Lawless described the hospital as being in a crisis situation.

His understanding is an additional 30 nurses are โ€œdesperately neededโ€ now.

In relation to beds, HSE West and Northwest said the average occupancy rate in Mayo is โ€œcurrently 113%โ€.

Hospital ‘routinely operated at about 120% capacity’

The inquest into Mr Rowlandโ€™s death heard the hospital โ€œroutinely operated at about 120% capacityโ€ then. The safe recommended level is 85% in any hospital.

CSO census data shows Mayoโ€™s population has the highest average age, followed by Kerry.

The ED has seen a 6% increase in patients aged over 75 since last year, the HSE said.

This meant 296 more patients by August.

The gap is even bigger compared to 2023 with 1,064 more older patients already seen.

Overall 124 patients were seen daily in August compared to 117 last August.

The HSE has funding for four geriatricians but only one permanent consultant in place. Locums fill the other roles while recruitment continues.

Injury unit at Ballina District Hospital

It is planning an injury unit at Ballina District Hospital. Phase 1 is expected to open by June 2026. Talks continue on how this will work including who will staff it.

The overcrowding was raised in the Dรกil in recent days in an exchange between health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill and local Aontu TD Paul Lawless. He described a patient waiting 13 hours in an ambulance outside the hospital.

Ms Carroll MacNeill described visiting Mayo hospital on a Saturday last month.

She said there were “practically no diagnostics going onโ€.

Asked about this, the HSE said: โ€œAdditional diagnostics appointments are being facilitated by extending hours in the unit โ€” an earlier start, later finish, and keeping scanners all through lunch in radiology.โ€

The hospital is also operating a Saturday and Sunday list.

The minister said the hospital has had a 30% staffing increase over five years, saying: โ€œMayo hospital is not understaffed. However, Mayo hospital is imbalanced.โ€

The HSE said: โ€œLike other hospitals, there are certain pockets of resources required to meet current demand.”

It referred to physiotherapy, dietitians, occupational therapists, and social workers. They are working on business cases โ€œwhere gaps in clinical specialties have been identifiedโ€.

In the meantime, Dr Cunningham called on people to come to the ED if they are unwell, saying โ€œlike clockworkโ€ they see numbers drop every time the crisis is highlighted.

โ€œPeople are afraid,โ€ she warned. โ€œThen when they do come a week or two later, they are quite unwell. That happens in every ED.โ€

Original source: ie